"Ain't gonna stop now
'cause I'm almost there..."
Tiana
"Almost There"
On my recent travels to NYC, I was fortunate enough to see the premiere of Disney’s The Princess and the Frog, the latest animated film in Disney’s Princess Collection. Having written a 300+ page thesis about Disney’s princesses (even referencing the highly anticipated 2009 debut of the first African American princess), I was both nervous and excited to see the most recent addition to the collection. On one hand, I was anticipating the traditional princess-finds-prince-happily-ever-after fairy tale Disney is known for. On the other hand, I had hope that this one -- which was a spin on the old fairy tale The Frog Prince -- would bring about changes in the traditional princess narrative. And, lucky for me (and for the young girls everywhere watching the film), I was pleasantly surprised.
The film focuses on the life of Tiana, a girl who is not technically a princess but who manages to live up to some pretty royal standards. She is, above all else, hard working and this is a quality that I was really pleased to see in Disney’s latest princess film. Unlike many of the princess figures that came before her (which include: Snow White, Cinderella, Aurora, Belle, Jasmine, Ariel, Pocahontas, and Mulan), Tiana has a goal and she works incredibly hard to go after it. Tiana is not waiting for a prince to save her. Tiana, while she does love to wish on stars, isn’t waiting around for some wish to be granted. For example, at one point in the song "When We're Human," Tiana sings,
"Your modesty becomes you
and your sense of responsibility
I worked hard for everything I got
and that's the way it's supposed to be
When I'm a human being
at least I'll act like one
if you do your best
each and every day
good things are sure to come your way
What you give is what you get!
My daddy said that
and now I'll never forget..."
As you can see from these lyrics (which contrast sharply with Prince Naveen's that include party-boy lyrics like "When I'm myself again/I want just the life I had/A great big party every night/that doesn't sound too bad/A redhead on my left arm/a brunette on my right/a blonde or two to hold a candle/that sounds just about right..." Yeah. I don't even know what to say about that, Disney.) Anyway, back to Tiana: She is constantly working hard to achieve her goals, something we saw more of with the most recent princesses Pocahontas and Mulan, but something we see a lot less of in the earlier (and more popular) princess films. Even Ariel in Disney’s The Little Mermaid, who works hard to achieve the goal of becoming human, has a goal that is quite directly tied to the idea of marriage and winning the love of Prince Eric. But little Ariel, who was considered to possess some feminist characteristics prevalent in the 1980s, can't hold a candle to the fiercely determined Tiana. The latest Disney princess works hard to achieve her own personal goal –- a goal that doesn't ultimately relate to falling safely into the arms of a man.
While, as you can imagine, romance is a focus in the film, it’s not the focus and, in fact, doesn’t really come into play until late in scripted narrative. What is the focus is Tiana and her hard working dedication to making her dream come true. (One small downside: The dream Tiana works towards is actually her father’s dream. Again, Disney struggles to make the female character completely independent from men in their personal desires.) For the first time since I’d seen Mulan, I was actually inspired by a Disney princess as I watched Tiana develop as a character. Sitting in the theater filled with squirming, princess-accessorized little girls, I was actually moved by how strong and how sure Tiana was throughout the film.
Tiana was filled with desire to make her dream come true -- a dream that veered from the traditional marriage-and-babies dream of many of the princesses (which was -- finally! -- mocked in the film through the actions of another character) -- and Tiana never gave up. It was her determination through all of her struggles (and she did have some struggles!) that filled me with hope for future generations of princess-loving little girls. With Tiana as a new role model, I began to have hope that little girls would be able to see that the life of a beautiful young woman didn’t have to center around love and marriage (though, of course, Disney couldn’t leave those elements out of the film). It became clear that the roles of female characters in animated pictures truly are changing and that girls will be able to look to characters like Tiana (and others, such as EVE in WALL-E) for inspiration and motivation.
Not only was Tiana determined to achieve her dream -- an element of the film that took precedence, for once, over romance -- but she was also amazingly composed in the face of danger and hardship. Tiana was flat-out brave, a wonderful characteristic for a princess. And, amidst all of her bravery and courage, Tiana was also kind, caring, and giving. Tiana put herself and her dreams first, but she also cared about the well-being of others. She was, in my opinion, an embodiment of so many good characteristics that create a person of good character. She was not passive or weak. She was not flighty or giggly. She was not cruel and insensitive. She was, instead, kind and generous and strong and courageous -- a mix of characteristics that are rare to see in a female in a Disney film.
Most Disney princess films that have come before The Princess and the Frog depict female characters as either passive and beautiful and in need of saving (the princesses) or as cruel and driven and willing to stop at nothing to get what they feel they deserve (the stepmothers and witches). The character of Tiana was a wonderful mix of strength and kindness, which provides a great foundation from which young girls can build upon. Tiana illustrates how a woman can be strong without losing some of the wonderful traits of being a woman. Often in film the strong women are given masculine characteristics, implying that women cannot be both feminine and possess strength. However, Tiana was an exception to this horrible rule. She was strong, confident, and dedicated to her dreams, but she was also kind and sweet and compassionate. (Not that men cannot be those things -- but in the stereotypes in films, these tend to be traits that are depicted in women.)
While I was very impressed with the character of Tiana (and who wouldn’t be after all of the other films I’ve seen!), I have to admit that the portrayal of the male character left something to be desired. The lead male character, Prince Naveen, was arrogant and loud, a show-off who’s main goal in life was having fun (preferably with a beautiful trail of women following him everywhere he went). Naveen embodied many of the negative (and stereotypical) characteristics that one would associate with a spoiled prince. He was cocky and self-obsessed, expecting others to cater to him and having little idea of how to do anything for himself. Though, in true Disney fashion, he does eventually come around to realizing what’s important in life, it would have been nice to have seen some of the complexities of his character earlier in the film. As with many characters in Disney’s princess films, Naveen was oversimplified and he was quickly categorized as a fun-loving playboy who’s main goal in life was finding a way to do what he wanted to do when he wanted to do it. Perhaps Disney focused so much on creating a dynamic, strong female character that they didn’t have the time (or energy) to make Naveen as interesting or complex.
Though I could go on and on about the various levels of the film -- and even some of the things about Tiana that were less than appealing to a feminist like me -- overall, I was pretty impressed with Disney revised take on The Frog Prince. Perhaps Disney somehow stumbled across my thesis and, after reading it, realized that a princess needed more in her life than a dream for a prince and hope for marriage. Disney’s take on Tiana -- and even on the topic of love -- was actually inspiring, an adjective I’d be hesitant to use with most of the other princess films. But I cannot deny that leaving the theater, my heart felt hopeful, and I honestly can say that if Disney continues to produce more princesses like Tiana I won’t have a problem with young girls wanting to grow up to be a princess.
I don't think Disney is quite making the kind of feminist female princesses that I hope to see in their films someday, but I do think they've come a long way since the last princess film and I'll give them credit for being almost there. And speaking of "almost there," check out the lyrics from one of my favorite songs in the film...
"Mama... I don't have time for dancing...
That's just gonna have to wait a while
Ain't got time for messing around
And it's not my style
This whole town can slow you down
People taking the easy way
But I know exactly where I'm going
And getting closer, closer, every day
And I'm almost there, I'm almost there
People down here think I'm crazy, but I don't care
Tribes and tribulations have had my share
There ain't nothing gonna stop me now cause I'm almost there
I remember Daddy told me, "Fairy tales can come true.
You gotta make 'em happen, it all depends on you."
So I work real hard each and every day
Now things for sure are going my way
Just doing what I do
Look out boys I'm coming through
And I'm almost there, I'm almost there
People gonna come here from everywhere
And I'm almost there, I'm almost there
There's been tribes and tribulations
You know I've had my share
But I've climbed the mountain, I've crossed the river
And I'm almost there, I'm almost there
I'm almost there!"
Almost there, Disney... almost there...
After writing this post, I was introduced to this video from Newsy, a site that analyzes news coverage from multiple sources to help viewers better understand complex issues. It's a great source to look at when you want to see a variety of opinions on the film. Check out the video, by clicking here.